Validation CAMS RADIATION - BSRN stations

Last update: Oct. 2019

CURRENT STATISTICS

Validation of CAMS Radiation (2004 - J-1) against the measurements of 21 BSRN stations

 

 

Date of the validation: May 2019
Current version of CAMS Radiation: 3.2
Network: Baseline Surface Radiation Network (BSRN). See whole list of BSRN stations.
Number of stations: 21 (see Table 1), located in the Meteosat Second Generation Prime satellite.
Original time step and radiation components: 1 min GHI and DNI
Author: Laurent Saboret, TRANSVALOR
Publication: -
Have a look to previous validation results (14 BSRN stations only and computed over a shorter period of time, CAMS Radiation version 3.0 Oct. 2017).


 

Illustration: list of the BSRN stations used for the validation =>

        

BSRN stations used in this validation

(Table 1: in decreasing latitudes)

Station Code Country Latitude Longitude Altitude (m) Period Type of Climate
Lerwick LER Scotland 60.139 -1.185 80 2004-02-01 to 2017-12-31 Oceanic
Toravere TOR Estonia 58.254 26.462 70 2004-02-01 to 2018-12-31 Continental
Lindenberg LIN Germany 52.210 14.122 125 2004-02-01 to 2017-12-31 Continental
Cabauw CAB The Netherlands 51.971 4.927 0 2005-01-01 to 2018-12-31 Oceanic
Camborne CAM United Kingdom 50.217 -5.317 88 2004-02-01 to 2017-12-31 Oceanic
Palaiseau PAL France 48.713 2.208 156 2004-02-01 to 2018-12-31 Continental
Sonnblick SON Austria 47.054 12.958 3109 2013-01-01 to 2018-12-31 Montaneous
Payerne PAY Switzerland 46.815 6.944 491 2004-02-01 to 2013-12-31 Continental
Carpentras CAR France 44.083 5.059 100 2004-02-01 to 2018-12-31 Mediterranean
Cener CEN Spain 42.816 -1.601 471 2009-01-01 to 2018-12-31 Oceanic
Eastern North Atlantic ENA Spain 39.091 -28.029 15 2013-01-01 to 2013-12-31 Oceanic
Sede Boqer SBO Israel 30.860 34.779 500 2004-02-01 to 2012-12-31 Desertic
Izaña IZA Spain 28.309 -16.499 2373 2009-01-01 to 2018-12-31 Oceanic Montaneous
Tamanrasset TAM Algeria 22.790 5.529 1385 2004-02-01 to 2018-12-31 Desertic
Ilorin ILO Nigeria 8.533 4.567 350 2004-02-01 to 2005-12-31 Equatorial
Petrolina PTR Brazil -9.068 -40.319 387 2008-01-01 to 2017-12-31 Subtropical
Brasilia BRB Brazil -15.601 -47.713 1023 2008-01-01 to 2015-12-31 Subtropical
Gobabeb GOB Namibia -23.561 15.042 407 2012-01-01 to 2018-12-31 Desertic
Florianopolis FLO Brasilia -27.605 -48.523 11 2013-01-01 to 2018-12-31 Subtropical
Sao Martinho da Serra SMS Brasilia -29.443 -53.823 489 2008-01-01 to 2017-12-31 Subtropical
De Aar DAA South Africa -30.667 23.993 1287 2004-02-01 to 2018-12-31 Desertic

Top of page

GHI and DNI CAMS Radiation validation results - monthly, daily, hourly and 15 min sampling rates

(Click on the following link to show the corresponding statistics)

Monthly GHI

CAMS-Radiation -- GHI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
MONTHLY IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(kWh/m2)
Bias
(kWh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(kWh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(kWh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 129 65.70 -1.83 (-2.79%) 3.79 (5.78%) 4.21 (6.42%) 0.997
Toravere 175 75.43 -0.37 (-0.49%) 5.23 (6.94%) 5.25 (6.96%) 0.996
Lindenberg 156 91.19 1.25 (1.37%) 4.76 (5.22%) 4.92 (5.39%) 0.997
Cabauw 164 90.62 4.59 (5.06%) 4.65 (5.13%) 6.53 (7.21%) 0.998
Camborne 117 92.10 3.28 (3.56%) 4.04 (4.39%) 5.20 (5.65%) 0.998
Palaiseau 147 98.27 3.20 (3.25%) 4.77 (4.85%) 5.74 (5.84%) 0.997
Sonnblick 63 98.23 -1.68 (-1.71%) 17.89 (18.21%) 17.96 (18.29%) 0.949
Payerne 117 99.94 4.50 (4.50%) 4.79 (4.79%) 6.57 (6.58%) 0.997
Carpentras 165 128.69 1.68 (1.30%) 3.23 (2.51%) 3.64 (2.83%) 0.999
Cener 107 118.50 1.67 (1.41%) 7.37 (6.22%) 7.56 (6.38%) 0.993
ENA, Azores 0 NaN NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN
Sede Boqer 100 168.22 -5.61 (-3.34%) 5.05 (3.00%) 7.55 (4.49%) 0.997
Izana, Tenerife 115 198.76 -4.65 (-2.34%) 7.26 (3.65%) 8.62 (4.34%) 0.993
Tamanrasset 176 168.88 -5.54 (-3.28%) 4.67 (2.77%) 7.25 (4.29%) 0.994
Ilorin 14 127.58 8.77 (6.87%) 5.13 (4.02%) 10.16 (7.96%) 0.964
Petrolina 102 152.56 8.10 (5.31%) 4.39 (2.88%) 9.21 (6.04%) 0.989
Brasilia 71 142.41 5.19 (3.65%) 4.63 (3.25%) 6.95 (4.88%) 0.988
Gobabeb 76 197.15 -9.66 (-4.90%) 3.42 (1.74%) 10.25 (5.20%) 0.999
Florianopolis 54 127.96 0.81 (0.63%) 4.13 (3.23%) 4.21 (3.29%) 0.993
Sao Martinho da Serra 98 137.19 -0.34 (-0.25%) 5.27 (3.84%) 5.28 (3.85%) 0.994
De Aar 53 172.96 -3.94 (-2.28%) 2.36 (1.36%) 4.59 (2.66%) 0.999

Daily GHI

CAMS-Radiation -- GHI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
DAILY IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(Wh/m2)
Bias
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 3718 2284.88 -64.24 (-2.81%) 522.89 (22.88%) 526.82 (23.06%) 0.966
Toravere 5044 2553.20 -9.99 (-0.39%) 445.95 (17.47%) 446.06 (17.47%) 0.980
Lindenberg 4694 3028.71 40.99 (1.35%) 410.60 (13.56%) 412.64 (13.62%) 0.984
Cabauw 4873 3039.46 153.78 (5.06%) 398.40 (13.11%) 427.05 (14.05%) 0.984
Camborne 3470 3110.71 110.99 (3.57%) 506.24 (16.27%) 518.27 (16.66%) 0.974
Palaiseau 4428 3262.90 108.26 (3.32%) 398.89 (12.22%) 413.32 (12.67%) 0.984
Sonnblick 1603 3714.98 -53.06 (-1.43%) 1051.07 (28.29%) 1052.41 (28.33%) 0.875
Payerne 3416 3379.72 152.33 (4.51%) 400.91 (11.86%) 428.87 (12.69%) 0.986
Carpentras 4889 4349.36 56.15 (1.29%) 331.12 (7.61%) 335.84 (7.72%) 0.991
Cener 3121 4022.43 57.51 (1.43%) 485.26 (12.06%) 488.66 (12.15%) 0.979
ENA, Azores 18 2977.59 -99.14 (-3.33%) 97.44 (3.27%) 139.01 (4.67%) 0.992
Sede Boqer 2871 5774.59 -189.68 (-3.28%) 376.00 (6.51%) 421.14 (7.29%) 0.984
Izana, Tenerife 3393 6713.59 -162.17 (-2.42%) 850.42 (12.67%) 865.74 (12.90%) 0.916
Tamanrasset 4795 5909.86 -181.06 (-3.06%) 422.69 (7.15%) 459.84 (7.78%) 0.961
Ilorin 366 4557.47 327.22 (7.18%) 450.67 (9.89%) 556.93 (12.22%) 0.850
Petrolina 2897 5509.75 288.88 (5.24%) 396.44 (7.20%) 490.53 (8.90%) 0.956
Brasilia 2020 5250.32 180.29 (3.43%) 561.72 (10.70%) 589.94 (11.24%) 0.914
Gobabeb 2276 6578.97 -322.38 (-4.90%) 288.43 (4.38%) 432.57 (6.58%) 0.985
Florianopolis 1647 4291.22 25.32 (0.59%) 610.55 (14.23%) 611.08 (14.24%) 0.955
Sao Martinho da Serra 2934 4745.82 -17.71 (-0.37%) 500.38 (10.54%) 500.69 (10.55%) 0.978
De Aar 1575 5779.27 -130.86 (-2.26%) 335.44 (5.80%) 360.06 (6.23%) 0.988

Hourly GHI

CAMS-Radiation -- GHI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
HOURLY IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(Wh/m2)
Bias
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 43011 197.47 -5.63 (-2.85%) 76.25 (38.62%) 76.46 (38.72%) 0.914
Toravere 56985 218.94 -0.19 (-0.09%) 66.52 (30.38%) 66.52 (30.38%) 0.949
Lindenberg 55145 257.38 3.32 (1.29%) 65.84 (25.58%) 65.93 (25.61%) 0.957
Cabauw 57932 255.63 12.76 (4.99%) 62.08 (24.29%) 63.38 (24.79%) 0.961
Camborne 41133 262.38 9.14 (3.48%) 76.59 (29.19%) 77.13 (29.40%) 0.944
Palaiseau 52259 276.23 8.97 (3.25%) 65.19 (23.60%) 65.80 (23.82%) 0.961
Sonnblick 19182 314.70 -5.22 (-1.66%) 137.17 (43.59%) 137.27 (43.62%) 0.843
Payerne 39300 291.49 13.30 (4.56%) 65.38 (22.43%) 66.71 (22.89%) 0.967
Carpentras 58998 360.17 4.47 (1.24%) 55.04 (15.28%) 55.23 (15.33%) 0.980
Cener 37809 333.60 4.53 (1.36%) 73.57 (22.05%) 73.71 (22.09%) 0.963
ENA, Azores 367 234.29 -7.92 (-3.38%) 39.46 (16.84%) 40.25 (17.18%) 0.985
Sede Boqer 32177 519.75 -17.22 (-3.31%) 58.25 (11.21%) 60.74 (11.69%) 0.982
Izana, Tenerife 41560 545.29 -12.65 (-2.32%) 101.89 (18.69%) 102.67 (18.83%) 0.955
Tamanrasset 58579 495.40 -15.93 (-3.22%) 68.49 (13.83%) 70.32 (14.19%) 0.978
Ilorin 4103 464.48 30.25 (6.51%) 84.87 (18.27%) 90.10 (19.40%) 0.947
Petrolina 34940 457.28 24.04 (5.26%) 75.28 (16.46%) 79.02 (17.28%) 0.972
Brasilia 24851 435.29 19.21 (4.41%) 120.77 (27.74%) 122.29 (28.09%) 0.921
Gobabeb 28380 527.30 -25.84 (-4.90%) 44.32 (8.41%) 51.31 (9.73%) 0.992
Florianopolis 19369 364.87 2.18 (0.60%) 103.27 (28.30%) 103.29 (28.31%) 0.935
Sao Martinho da Serra 35327 395.20 -1.65 (-0.42%) 85.16 (21.55%) 85.18 (21.55%) 0.961
De Aar 18301 498.45 -11.29 (-2.26%) 59.40 (11.92%) 60.47 (12.13%) 0.983

15 min GHI

CAMS-Radiation -- GHI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
15 MIN IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(Wh/m2)
Bias
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 170231 50.18 -1.37 (-2.74%) 23.21 (46.25%) 23.25 (46.33%) 0.879
Toravere 223906 58.95 -0.29 (-0.49%) 22.20 (37.65%) 22.20 (37.66%) 0.921
Lindenberg 214543 66.31 0.91 (1.37%) 22.09 (33.31%) 22.11 (33.34%) 0.926
Cabauw 224305 66.26 3.35 (5.06%) 20.91 (31.57%) 21.18 (31.97%) 0.933
Camborne 159715 67.74 2.41 (3.56%) 23.83 (35.18%) 23.95 (35.36%) 0.917
Palaiseau 203241 71.22 2.38 (3.34%) 22.13 (31.07%) 22.25 (31.25%) 0.932
Sonnblick 74241 84.80 -1.52 (-1.79%) 39.96 (47.12%) 39.99 (47.16%) 0.801
Payerne 154191 76.33 3.43 (4.50%) 21.60 (28.29%) 21.87 (28.65%) 0.945
Carpentras 226819 93.79 1.22 (1.30%) 17.84 (19.03%) 17.89 (19.07%) 0.966
Cener 144858 87.53 1.23 (1.41%) 23.75 (27.13%) 23.78 (27.17%) 0.939
ENA, Azores 1637 68.33 -2.86 (-4.19%) 15.99 (23.40%) 16.25 (23.78%) 0.963
Sede Boqer 127734 133.31 -4.45 (-3.34%) 18.17 (13.63%) 18.71 (14.03%) 0.972
Izana, Tenerife 156756 145.82 -3.41 (-2.34%) 29.29 (20.09%) 29.49 (20.22%) 0.939
Tamanrasset 226409 131.28 -4.31 (-3.28%) 22.70 (17.29%) 23.11 (17.60%) 0.961
Ilorin 17219 117.29 7.75 (6.61%) 27.82 (23.72%) 28.88 (24.63%) 0.916
Petrolina 133429 121.21 6.37 (5.26%) 26.44 (21.82%) 27.20 (22.44%) 0.941
Brasilia 95866 114.77 5.32 (4.63%) 39.72 (34.61%) 40.08 (34.92%) 0.867
Gobabeb 106448 140.76 -6.90 (-4.90%) 14.08 (10.00%) 15.68 (11.14%) 0.985
Florianopolis 75344 94.03 0.66 (0.70%) 31.79 (33.81%) 31.80 (33.82%) 0.905
Sao Martinho da Serra 135035 104.11 -0.35 (-0.34%) 28.08 (26.97%) 28.08 (26.98%) 0.934
De Aar 70301 130.62 -2.96 (-2.27%) 20.77 (15.90%) 20.98 (16.06%) 0.965

Monthly DNI

CAMS-Radiation -- DNI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
MONTHLY IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(kWh/m2)
Bias
(kWh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(kWh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(kWh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 16 84.43 -19.32 (-22.88%) 6.85 (8.12%) 20.49 (24.27%) 0.962
Toravere 80 135.95 -22.55 (-16.58%) 11.50 (8.46%) 25.31 (18.62%) 0.957
Lindenberg 100 114.60 -6.06 (-5.29%) 7.34 (6.41%) 9.52 (8.31%) 0.981
Cabauw 97 101.07 6.86 (6.79%) 6.57 (6.50%) 9.50 (9.40%) 0.979
Camborne 65 96.69 6.17 (6.38%) 7.27 (7.52%) 9.53 (9.86%) 0.976
Palaiseau 95 109.87 1.78 (1.62%) 7.52 (6.84%) 7.72 (7.03%) 0.978
Sonnblick 27 119.76 -0.18 (-0.15%) 31.94 (26.67%) 31.94 (26.67%) 0.480
Payerne 58 136.64 1.61 (1.18%) 7.61 (5.57%) 7.78 (5.70%) 0.979
Carpentras 163 156.05 -5.15 (-3.30%) 5.85 (3.75%) 7.80 (5.00%) 0.995
Cener 90 135.60 -3.45 (-2.54%) 9.64 (7.11%) 10.24 (7.55%) 0.982
ENA, Azores 0 NaN NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN
Sede Boqer 97 183.32 -26.75 (-14.59%) 13.05 (7.12%) 29.76 (16.23%) 0.974
Izana, Tenerife 112 258.10 -16.76 (-6.49%) 29.92 (11.59%) 34.29 (13.29%) 0.904
Tamanrasset 159 174.28 1.85 (1.06%) 20.05 (11.50%) 20.13 (11.55%) 0.915
Ilorin 0 NaN NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN
Petrolina 79 136.46 13.17 (9.65%) 8.04 (5.89%) 15.43 (11.31%) 0.973
Brasilia 46 139.62 3.51 (2.51%) 6.84 (4.90%) 7.69 (5.50%) 0.991
Gobabeb 76 242.76 -31.46 (-12.96%) 8.89 (3.66%) 32.69 (13.47%) 0.970
Florianopolis 41 112.11 -0.12 (-0.11%) 7.76 (6.93%) 7.77 (6.93%) 0.946
Sao Martinho da Serra 43 135.30 -7.24 (-5.35%) 9.28 (6.86%) 11.78 (8.70%) 0.965
De Aar 53 226.95 -14.82 (-6.53%) 9.11 (4.01%) 17.40 (7.67%) 0.980

Daily DNI

CAMS-Radiation -- DNI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
DAILY IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(Wh/m2)
Bias
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 851 3794.42 -1064.67 (-28.06%) 1145.26 (30.18%) 1563.70 (41.21%) 0.876
Toravere 1892 6027.86 -1266.08 (-21.00%) 1038.55 (17.23%) 1637.54 (27.17%) 0.935
Lindenberg 2231 5167.14 -408.84 (-7.91%) 847.53 (16.40%) 940.99 (18.21%) 0.944
Cabauw 2316 4707.07 70.11 (1.49%) 866.41 (18.41%) 869.24 (18.47%) 0.939
Camborne 1482 4599.24 93.96 (2.04%) 1026.76 (22.32%) 1031.05 (22.42%) 0.921
Palaiseau 2109 5069.97 -74.91 (-1.48%) 868.18 (17.12%) 871.40 (17.19%) 0.942
Sonnblick 738 6200.25 -721.13 (-11.63%) 2390.22 (38.55%) 2496.63 (40.27%) 0.701
Payerne 1434 6124.39 -92.76 (-1.51%) 876.90 (14.32%) 881.79 (14.40%) 0.940
Carpentras 3684 6654.60 -264.00 (-3.97%) 722.23 (10.85%) 768.97 (11.56%) 0.962
Cener 1948 6125.59 -234.58 (-3.83%) 889.86 (14.53%) 920.26 (15.02%) 0.946
ENA, Azores 14 4798.62 -251.86 (-5.25%) 458.45 (9.55%) 523.08 (10.90%) 0.869
Sede Boqer 2621 6661.27 -955.97 (-14.35%) 978.58 (14.69%) 1368.03 (20.54%) 0.903
Izana, Tenerife 3029 9477.09 -703.50 (-7.42%) 2417.75 (25.51%) 2518.02 (26.57%) 0.586
Tamanrasset 3836 6658.53 9.95 (0.15%) 1187.55 (17.84%) 1187.60 (17.84%) 0.879
Ilorin 0 NaN NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN
Petrolina 2112 5803.99 556.66 (9.59%) 866.31 (14.93%) 1029.74 (17.74%) 0.904
Brasilia 1139 5752.45 137.49 (2.39%) 885.75 (15.40%) 896.36 (15.58%) 0.916
Gobabeb 2180 8343.83 -1091.18 (-13.08%) 719.27 (8.62%) 1306.91 (15.66%) 0.916
Florianopolis 846 5544.20 -41.45 (-0.75%) 1071.57 (19.33%) 1072.37 (19.34%) 0.890
Sao Martinho da Serra 1188 6607.85 -304.82 (-4.61%) 1127.28 (17.06%) 1167.77 (17.67%) 0.904
De Aar 1427 8208.20 -535.95 (-6.53%) 718.53 (8.75%) 896.39 (10.92%) 0.962

Hourly DNI

CAMS-Radiation -- DNI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
HOURLY IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(Wh/m2)
Bias
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 14465 305.83 -82.33 (-26.92%) 181.44 (59.33%) 199.25 (65.15%) 0.694
Toravere 29863 452.95 -96.20 (-21.24%) 163.40 (36.07%) 189.61 (41.86%) 0.827
Lindenberg 31654 404.25 -29.10 (-7.20%) 138.56 (34.28%) 141.58 (35.02%) 0.862
Cabauw 33851 366.11 13.07 (3.57%) 133.37 (36.43%) 134.01 (36.60%) 0.863
Camborne 20952 368.25 13.36 (3.63%) 159.28 (43.25%) 159.84 (43.40%) 0.819
Palaiseau 29844 398.41 0.44 (0.11%) 134.64 (33.79%) 134.64 (33.79%) 0.874
Sonnblick 10922 490.17 -33.24 (-6.78%) 320.24 (65.33%) 321.96 (65.68%) 0.608
Payerne 21037 481.75 -1.47 (-0.30%) 139.01 (28.86%) 139.02 (28.86%) 0.883
Carpentras 45865 553.08 -20.41 (-3.69%) 114.26 (20.66%) 116.07 (20.99%) 0.920
Cener 26383 485.94 -15.21 (-3.13%) 140.82 (28.98%) 141.64 (29.15%) 0.891
ENA, Azores 234 515.14 -34.64 (-6.72%) 114.19 (22.17%) 119.33 (23.16%) 0.912
Sede Boqer 29004 606.16 -85.50 (-14.11%) 144.40 (23.82%) 167.81 (27.68%) 0.877
Izana, Tenerife 37340 773.96 -55.43 (-7.16%) 251.09 (32.44%) 257.14 (33.22%) 0.681
Tamanrasset 48043 573.25 4.84 (0.84%) 149.89 (26.15%) 149.97 (26.16%) 0.889
Ilorin 0 NaN NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN
Petrolina 24984 498.85 47.15 (9.45%) 150.80 (30.23%) 158.00 (31.67%) 0.866
Brasilia 14551 490.16 10.60 (2.16%) 162.21 (33.09%) 162.55 (33.16%) 0.851
Gobabeb 26215 701.52 -92.47 (-13.18%) 98.80 (14.08%) 135.32 (19.29%) 0.946
Florianopolis 10183 507.97 -7.79 (-1.53%) 184.64 (36.35%) 184.80 (36.38%) 0.818
Sao Martinho da Serra 15550 528.65 -12.74 (-2.41%) 198.26 (37.50%) 198.67 (37.58%) 0.809
De Aar 16738 708.34 -45.93 (-6.48%) 112.78 (15.92%) 121.78 (17.19%) 0.937

15 min DNI

CAMS-Radiation -- DNI Quality assessment results vs. the stations
15 MIN IRRADIATION
Station Number of values Mean
station
(Wh/m2)
Bias
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
STDEV
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
RMSE
(Wh/m2)
(relative in %)
Correl. coeff.
Lerwick 62347 73.61 -18.49 (-25.12%) 56.29 (76.47%) 59.25 (80.49%) 0.599
Toravere 126857 113.65 -23.50 (-20.68%) 52.01 (45.77%) 57.08 (50.22%) 0.756
Lindenberg 129615 100.83 -6.29 (-6.24%) 45.46 (45.09%) 45.90 (45.52%) 0.786
Cabauw 137259 92.16 4.84 (5.25%) 43.67 (47.38%) 43.93 (47.67%) 0.789
Camborne 85170 92.13 4.99 (5.41%) 50.36 (54.66%) 50.61 (54.93%) 0.742
Palaiseau 121920 99.51 1.24 (1.24%) 44.24 (44.46%) 44.26 (44.48%) 0.803
Sonnblick 44742 124.32 -3.49 (-2.81%) 94.23 (75.79%) 94.29 (75.85%) 0.511
Payerne 88243 120.38 1.04 (0.87%) 45.44 (37.75%) 45.45 (37.76%) 0.819
Carpentras 182552 140.28 -4.62 (-3.30%) 37.07 (26.42%) 37.36 (26.63%) 0.870
Cener 105598 123.32 -2.79 (-2.26%) 45.85 (37.18%) 45.93 (37.25%) 0.826
ENA, Azores 1149 132.41 -9.09 (-6.87%) 40.54 (30.61%) 41.54 (31.37%) 0.839
Sede Boqer 117127 155.25 -22.61 (-14.56%) 42.03 (27.07%) 47.73 (30.74%) 0.831
Izana, Tenerife 142921 204.61 -13.69 (-6.69%) 71.90 (35.14%) 73.19 (35.77%) 0.552
Tamanrasset 190748 148.48 1.90 (1.28%) 44.20 (29.77%) 44.24 (29.80%) 0.846
Ilorin 0 NaN NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN (NaN%) NaN
Petrolina 96929 130.02 13.01 (10.01%) 49.58 (38.13%) 51.26 (39.42%) 0.777
Brasilia 57904 127.54 3.79 (2.97%) 54.06 (42.39%) 54.20 (42.49%) 0.754
Gobabeb 98730 186.87 -24.21 (-12.96%) 31.52 (16.87%) 39.75 (21.27%) 0.890
Florianopolis 43158 122.22 -0.54 (-0.44%) 57.17 (46.78%) 57.17 (46.78%) 0.759
Sao Martinho da Serra 61077 137.07 -1.47 (-1.07%) 61.58 (44.93%) 61.60 (44.94%) 0.716
De Aar 64990 185.12 -12.07 (-6.52%) 40.09 (21.66%) 41.87 (22.62%) 0.863

Top of page